I doubt anyone will read this but I've noticed that reviews on NG tend to be more so comments than critique. If NG members knew how to leave a solid review this wouldn't be an issue however I feel many break the rules.

For example I left a review on a horrible animation (or should I call it a tween? SINCE THE WHOLE FLASH WAS TWEEN! Anyways it is called Resident Evil Pwanchi pt 5. I gave the movie a 4 star rating and called out all the errors LIKE IT SAYS IN THE REVIEW GUIDELINES, and to my suprise I see a review above me thats whole purpose is to insult my review rather than REVIEW THE FLASH which I'd like to add is AGAINST THE REVIEW GUIDELINES.

I will link you here, http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/revie ws/541029/18 the abusive review was left by a member called fuck-division and he/she said

"Joey-Kazaam here is some CONSTRUCTIVE TIPS for you.
shut your fucking mouth when you've submitted 65 piece of shit flashes, and the only award you have is a underdog award. Stop trying to talk like your some kind of flash guru "the guru is not impressed", you fucking know it all prick. Also kill yourself."

Now what amuses me is that that whole review simply slanders what I've said and also shows the authors immaturity as I left a review with tips instead of freaking saying he should stop animating all together because all he does is tween copy righted video game characters....

This is one little incident however I am making this blog post because this is actually an issue I've been noticing wide spread. I feel that a lot of NG members that are young show a lot of disrespect in their posts and simply ignore the review guidelines, so what should happen is

1) Reviewer selects a level to give the flash (No changes)
2) A drop down menu of all the factors that go into a review such as plot, setting, characters, etc are rated with a level beside it

I believe this would avoid any complications because this would not let the newgrounder type, therefore they cannot leave hateful comments.

Thoughts? Or does nobody give a shit? I thought it would be a nifty idea so I could get some ACTUAL CONSTRUCTIVE CRITICSM ON MY FLASHES.